Years ago, whilst I was still at school, I remember watching an episode of The Simpsons, in which Homer Simpson enters a sewer. Or more accurately, tries to enter a sewer, but due to his size gets stuck face down. This of course was supposed to be funny, and yes, at the time I thought it was. However, in real life, entering a confined space is no laughing matter.
In the August 2018 issue, Phil La Duke in his article ‘Instinctual Safety’ gave an actual example of a confined space entry that resulted in fatality. The confined space in question was a 15-foot drainage tunnel covered with a manhole cover. Not much different, from my distant memory, to the scene depicted in The Simpsons’ episode.
One of the causes for the tragic accident and loss of life was that they did not test the air quality before entering the tunnel. Asphyxiation, or the deprivation of oxygen, can result in unconsciousness and often death, and is one of the main results of failing to test and monitor the atmosphere in a confined space.
The recognition of a confined space is the first step in preventing related fatalities. Since deaths in confined spaces often occur because the atmosphere is ‘oxygen-deficient’, toxic or combustible, confined spaces that contain or have the potential to contain a serious atmospheric hazard must have continual atmospheric testing and monitoring.
There are several definitions for what a confined space is, but the main principles are the same. A confined space is defined as a space that is:
- Not designed for continuous human occupancy
- Has limited or restricted means of entry and / or exit
- Is large enough for a person to enter and perform work
- Contains, or has a known potential to contain, a hazardous atmosphere
- Contains material for potential engulfment
- Has an internal design that could entrap or asphyxiate the entrant
Confined spaces include but are not limited to:
- Storage tanks, tank cars, process vessels, boilers, pressure vessels, silos and other tank-like compartments
- Open-topped spaces such as pits or degreasers
- Pipes, sewers, shafts, ducts and similar structures
- Any shipboard spaces entered through a small hatchway or access point, cargo tanks, cellular double bottom tanks, duct keels, ballast and oil tanks, and void spaces, but not including dry cargo holds
“the recognition of a confined space is the first step in preventing related fatalities”
Atmospheric testing and monitoring is vital for activities involving entry into a confined space. This article is intended to provide general information and to act as a reminder of the dangers associated with atmospheric hazards in a confined space. However, it does recognise that there are other hazards, too.
Atmospheric hazards in confined spaces
Atmospheric testing is required for evaluation of the hazards of the confined space and verification that acceptable conditions exist for entry into that space. Continuous atmospheric monitoring is then required to ensure that the conditions in the confined space have not changed after the initial testing. Atmospheric hazards in confined spaces are those that expose entrants to a risk such as entrapment, injury, acute illness or death from one of the following causes:
- Oxygen (deficiency or enrichment)
- Combustible gases
- Toxic gases
Oxygen (deficiency or enrichment)
We all know oxygen is vital for human survival, too little of it and it will affect our health adversely or result in death. Going back to the May 2018 issue, I wrote about safety footwear in my article ‘Stepping into Safety’. There I gave an account of my experience of choosing adequate safety footwear for climbing Mount Kilimanjaro. The most challenging part of the climb was adapting to the oxygen deficient atmosphere. It plays havoc with human physical and mental capability, as detailed in Table 1 below. However, too much of the oxygen in the air makes the atmosphere extremely flammable.
Oxygen deficiency: atmospheric oxygen concentration below 19.5%
Oxygen enrichment: atmospheric oxygen concentration above 23.5%
The potential effects of an oxygen deficient and enriched atmosphere vary dependent on how far from 19.5% to 23.5% atmospheric oxygen one is. The table below is simply a guide and should not be used as a definite. The effects on the human body vary due to the individual’s health and physical ability.
A gas that burns, a flammable gas, or vapour, in excess of 10% of its lower explosive limit (LEL) but below its upper explosive limit (UEL).
Lower Explosive Limit, is defined as the lowest concentration (by percentage) of a gas or vapour in air that is capable of producing a flash of fire in the presence of an ignition source (arc, flame, heat). Concentrations lower than the Lower Explosive Limit are ‘too lean’ to burn.
Upper Explosive Limit, is the highest concentration (percentage) of a gas or vapour in air capable of producing a flash of fire in the presence of an ignition source (arch, flame, heat). Concentrations higher than UEL are ‘too rich’ to burn.
The level of LEL and UEL is usually calculated as Percent by Volume. In this article we do not engage in the calculation, however it is vital to understand that testing the atmosphere is not a simple activity, both training, competence in general, and adequate equipment must be available and used.
Many gases have toxic properties that are harmful to living things. In the United States many of these gases have been assigned an NFPA 704 health rating of four (may be fatal) or three (may cause serious or permanent injury), and/or exposure limits determined by the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) professional association. In the UK these limits are defined by the Health and Safety Executive Publication – EH40 Workplace Exposure Limits.
Some, but by no means all, toxic gases are detectable by odour which can serve as a warning. However, not all of them, so odour should not be relied upon since some gases, such as H2S, paralyses the olfactory nerve leading to a loss of smell, leading a person to potentially think that the gas is no longer present. Hence, detection of toxic gases should not be left to an individual nose and sense of smell.
“toxicity of a substance can be affected by many different factors, such as the pathway of administration, the time of exposure, and the number of exposures”
Toxicity of a substance can be affected by many different factors, such as the pathway of administration, the time of exposure, the number of exposures, the physical form of the toxicant, the genetic makeup of an individual, an individual’s overall health, and many others. Limits have been set by different standards to control workplace exposure. These various standards are confusing and make it impossible to determine the toxicity without specialist test equipment. Some of these standards are:
- The Threshold Limit Value (TLV) of a chemical substance establishes the reasonable level to which a worker may be repeatedly exposed, day after day, over a working lifetime without adverse health effects. TLV is a reserved term of the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH).
- British work exposure limits (WELs) are set in order to help protect the health of workers. WELs are concentrations of hazardous substances in the air, averaged over a specified period of time, referred to as a time-weighted average (TWA). Two time periods are used: long-term (8 hours); and short-term (15 minutes). EH40/2005 Workplace exposure limits containing the list of workplace exposure limits for use with the Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations (as amended 2011).
- The Permissible Exposure Limit (PEL or OSHA PEL) is a TLV established by OSHA in the US for exposure of an employee to a substance or physical agent and may differ from TLVs in other jurisdictions. A PEL is usually given as a time-weighted average (TWA).
- RELs or Recommended Exposure Limits are TLVs established by NIOSH for exposure of an employee to a substance or physical agent.
- In Qatar for example, WELs are based on the UK standards, EH40 – Qatar Construction Specifications 2014.
Testing and monitoring
Testing the air inside a confined space is required prior to entering. The testing for atmospheric hazards should be done remotely before entering the confined space. Testing should be done in the order described below:
- Ensure proper oxygen levels are present (19.5% – 23.5%)
- Ensure that conbustible gases are not present
- Ensure that the toxic gases are within the permissible exposure limits
Air samples should be taken at several levels within the confined space; at the top, middle and bottom to locate varying concentrations of gases and vapours. Some gases are lighter than air and would collect at the top of a confined space. Others are heavier than air and would settle near or at the bottom of a confined space. And some gases are the same weight as air, which will be found throughout the confined space.
After the initial testing, remember to continuously monitor the confined space as the atmospheric conditions can change. A dedicated, competent person should be stationed at the confined space, while work is being undertaken, to carry out continuous monitoring.
There are various types of atmospheric testing and monitoring equipment, including fixed gas detectors and portable devices. Fixed type detectors are generally mounted near the process area of a plant or control room, or an area to be protected, in this instance the confined space. Portable detectors are used to monitor the atmosphere around personnel and are either hand-held or worn on clothing or on a belt/harness. Dependent upon the size and nature of the confined space, the work may require the workers to work remote from the entry point, e.g. in a sewer. In such instances workers would often utilise a portable continuous monitoring device.
There is a wealth of options out there, from budget single-gas monitors to industrial multi-gas detectors. The most common are multi-gas detectors, which usually detect and alert for four dangerous and common gasses as standard. Typically, these detectors would measure the level of oxygen (% O2), and other gases calibrated dependent upon the nature of the risk such as carbon monoxide (CO), hydrogen sulphide (H2S).
All gas detectors must be calibrated on a schedule. Portables devices must be calibrated more frequently due to the regular changes in environment they experience. A typical calibration schedule for a fixed system may be quarterly, bi-annually or even annually for more robust units. A typical calibration schedule for a portable gas detector is a daily “bump test” accompanied by a monthly calibration. Almost every portable gas detector requires a specific calibration gas which is available from the manufacturer.
The willingness of people to enter a confined space is often due to the fact that it is not recognised as a ‘confined space’ and then the failure to understand the risks is often the result of the lack of knowledge and awareness of the hazards.
Having got this far, and if the confined space is identified and clearly labelled and a risk assessment is undertaken, it is then often the apparent complexity and technical nature of the requirements to undertake atmospheric testing and monitoring that prevent effective control and mitigation of the atmospheric hazards in the confined space. Add to this the challenges of language barriers faced within the workforce in the middle east and work in confined spaces becomes even more deadly.