Open HSME menu
Subscribe Login

Home / Articles and Press Releases / Article / A Degree of Safety

CATEGORIES

  • Latest Issue
  • Above The Neck Protection
  • Chemical Protection
  • Confined Space
  • Construction
  • Emergency Procedures
  • Energy, Oil, and Mining Industries
  • Eye Protection
  • Fall Protection
  • Gas Detection
  • Hand Protection
  • Hazardous and Explosive Atmospheres
  • Health and Safety Awareness
  • Hearing Protection
  • Heat
  • Lighting and ATEX
  • Noise Monitoring
  • Personal Protective Equipment
  • Respiratory Protection
  • Safety Footwear
  • Safety Technology
  • Safety Training
  • Slips, Trips, and Falls
  • Wellbeing at work
  • Working at Height
  • Working rights

MORE

  • Press Release
  • Events
  • Videos
  • Webinars
  • Magazines

COMPANY

  • About
  • Advertising
  • Newsletter
  • Contact
Open HSME menu
Subscribe

Home / Articles and Press Releases / Article / A Degree of Safety

CATEGORIES

  • Latest Issue
  • Above The Neck Protection
  • Chemical Protection
  • Confined Space
  • Construction
  • Emergency Procedures
  • Energy, Oil, and Mining Industries
  • Eye Protection
  • Fall Protection
  • Gas Detection
  • Hand Protection
  • Hazardous and Explosive Atmospheres
  • Health and Safety Awareness
  • Hearing Protection
  • Heat
  • Lighting and ATEX
  • Noise Monitoring
  • Personal Protective Equipment
  • Respiratory Protection
  • Safety Footwear
  • Safety Technology
  • Safety Training
  • Slips, Trips, and Falls
  • Wellbeing at work
  • Working at Height
  • Working rights

MORE

  • Press Release
  • Events
  • Videos
  • Webinars
  • Magazines

COMPANY

  • About
  • Advertising
  • Newsletter
  • Contact

CATEGORIES

  • Safety Signage
  • Heat and Flame
  • Article
  • Press Release
  • Air Pollution
  • Above The Neck Protection
  • Chemical Protection
  • Confined Space
  • Construction
  • Emergency Procedures
  • Energy, Oil, and Mining Industries
  • Eye Protection
  • Fall Protection
  • Gas Detection
  • Hand Protection
  • Hazardous and Explosive Atmospheres
  • Health and Safety Awareness
  • Hearing Protection
  • Heat
  • Lighting and ATEX
  • Noise Monitoring
  • Offshore Platform Safety
  • Personal Protective Equipment
  • Regulations & Legislations
  • Respiratory Protection
  • Safety Footwear
  • Safety Technology
  • Safety Training
  • Slips, Trips, and Falls
  • Wellbeing at work
  • Working at Height
  • Working rights

Article

A Degree of Safety

A Degree of Safety

Inus Labuschagne

By Inus Labuschagne

| Read Bio

Published: March 09th, 2022

Share this article

Various fire incidents recently occurred underground, and each fire had the potential to result in a major incident. No lives were lost during any of these fires, but some necessitated the activation of emergency and escape procedures.

During investigation it was found that none of these fire detection monitors registered conditions that would trigger fire alarms in the control rooms at the mines. All incidents of conveyor belt related fires were detected by the early observations of employees working in relative proximity, or passing by the locations where the fires originated.

As a result, a decision was made to investigate opportunities for improvement in the effectiveness of the fire detection systems currently deployed in the underground mining facilities of some collieries. A case study involving some underground collieries was done to determine the effectiveness of their fire detection systems and identify the aspects that could be improved.

These collieries mostly use telemetric continuous monitoring fire detection systems with carbon monoxide (CO) sensor technology, aimed at reacting to the concentration of CO released during a condition of combustion. It is known that when smoke containing high CO concentrations is generated, the material is already heated beyond the designed operating temperature and is approaching its flash point, leaving an extremely limited margin for reaction time before the open fire occurs.

In this case study, 29 fire incidents were considered and their grouping is tabled in Figure 1. Furthermore, conveyor belt operations contributed to 83% (24 of the 29) of all these incidents.

A Degree of Safety
Figure 1: Fire causes per category

The Case for Change

From this investigation, it was clear that drastic improvement in the effectiveness of fire detection systems was required. Various aspects of the fire detection process were assessed for effectiveness. The objective of this initiative was to investigate the responses of existing toxic gas detection devices and/or new technology of fire and toxic gas detection devices that would trigger emergency actions at their soonest to prevent fires from reaching life threatening conditions. The focus was on conveyor belt trajectories and conveyor belt material, along with their payload.

The most critical aspects are briefly addressed in this report.

Constraint 1:

Single Detection Gas Dependency

The use of CO sensors did not only provide early detection, as per our expectation, but we also found that the material needs to be in an advanced state of combustion  for alarm conditions in order for CO to be liberated. The need was to identify at least one additional toxic substance that would be released and detected while the material was being heated, before the combustion reached flame propagation. This substance would act in combination with the CO toxin as a fire indicator.

Early Warning Toxin Indicators

Fire detection trials were conducted at the Kloppersbos testing facility of the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) in South Africa for alternative early warning toxin indicators. The following chemicals that were detected during previous conveyor belt tests for toxicity in a laboratory, that are also listed as potentially lethal, were assessed:

HBrHydrogen Bromide
HCLHydrogen Chloride
HCNHydrogen Cyanide
HFHydrogen Fluoride
H2SHydrogen Sulphide
N2ONitrous Oxide
SO2Sulphur Dioxide
COCI2Phosgene
COCarbon Monoxide
CO2Carbon Dioxide

Fires and Explosions Test Facility

A Degree of Safety
Image 1: Schematic layout of the fire testing tunnel

The CSIR-managed fires and explosions testing, training, research and development facility at Kloppersbos helps achieve safe working conditions for South Africans in industries where fires and explosions may occur. The facility provides a full-scale surface testing facility for the evaluation of underground explosion suppression systems, the flammability of conveyor belts, dust suppression systems for continuous miners, and similar investigations.

The unique location and size of the facility allows for the demonstration of large-scale coal dust/methane explosions, making it an ideal venue for basic and refresher training sessions for underground workers.

A schematic layout of the fire testing tunnel is presented in Image 1. The two air tunnels shown at the top of the layout are connected to a centrifugal fan providing thorough ventilation for the testing facility to resemble underground ventilation conditions.

Image 2 is a picture of the test facility where a 1.8 metre x 4.0 metre length of conveyor belt is set on fire. The performance and behaviour of the fire is monitored by multiple sensors placed on the other side of the fire and downstream from the observing team. The heat source underneath the conveyor belt consists of six burners fuelled by Propane to produce 3000kW energy.

A Degree of Safety
Image 2: A picture of the fire test chamber with Propane burners

This picture was taken two minutes after the burners were ignited. The violent flame gives the impression that the conveyor belt is burning; however, the flames are from the burners themselves and the conveyor belt is merely in its smouldering stage. This is the key point at which to detect any fires in their infancy before the flash point is reached. This smouldering stage is where the early warning system is expected to respond, and where so many systems have failed in the past to detect a smouldering conveyor belt. At this point, it is important to note that the CO levels only reached 18ppm max. The CO level would only exceed the 18ppm much later once the flash point was reached, which occurred approximately 12 minutes into the fire.

Research Findings

The graph in Figure 2 shows the results from a conveyor belt fire test. This graph illustrates what toxins are released by the belt in its smouldering stage before the flash point is reached and during full combustion. These findings assisted in evolving current fire detection systems, mostly reliant on CO concentrations, into an early warning system to detect combustion before fires started.

A Degree of Safety
Figure 2: Toxins released during a conveyor belt fire

The graph was rescaled to 0.4-2 volt to show the relation between the gases detected as some sensor spans would over-shadow the other smaller gas ranges if kept in the ppm scale. For example, the carbon monoxide (CO) span was 500ppm compared to the phosgene (COCL2) span of only 1ppm.

It is important to understand the events that take place within the first 12 minutes, as they show that the CO sensor does not reach critical alarm point above 20ppm, yet a fire is raging on!

In a real-life scenario, relying on the CO sensor itself would have failed. There needs to be another deciding factor to determine the difference between a conveyor belt fire and, for example, a diesel vehicle parked near the sensor(s). The solution would be in the form of a combination of sensors that can be used to determine the difference, so that false alarms can be prevented and true alarms acted upon immediately within the shortest time possible.

The graph also shows that the SO2 sensor provided 11 minutes of early warning before combustion started. The CO concentration fluctuated in the same 11 minutes and consequently no CO alarm was reached. The short-term exposure limit (STEL) of 5ppm can be used as a guideline to trigger an alarm. The alarm would only then be deactivated if the SO2 reading reached ZERO ppm (if using a hysteresis triggered type setting).

Figure 3: A view of the first four minutes of the test

The behaviour of some toxic gases during the early stages of the combustion process is illustrated in Figure 3. The scale on the left of the graph is reflecting 0.35 to 0.65 volts. Although this test lasted 34 minutes, only the first four minutes is discussed here.

Image 3: A four-metre length of flame-retardant conveyor belt on fire

It is demonstrated that SO2 in the smouldering stage peaked at 11ppm and dropped to a low of 3.5ppm before the flash point was reached. The belt was absorbing the energy before it released “flash point”. Both CO and SO2 are present, however, CO also dropped which would never have indicated an alarm. Now if both CO and SO2 levels are present, a conveyor belt smouldering/burning is evident.

Image 3 is a picture of a conveyor belt on fire. This is a real-life scenario where only four metres of conveyor belt is on fire. The brownish colour of the smoke indicates that this belt has flame retardant properties. The smoke rollback is indicative of the heat intensity where smoke is then found to pollute airways in a mine that would normally not be considered affected by the fire.

Alarm Settings for Gas Detection Sensors

Absolute Values

In the scenarios assessed during the case study involving the six mines mentioned before, the first and second alarm levels for CO concentration were set at 30ppm and 100ppm absolute value respectively. These alarm levels were selected to eliminate the influence that exhaust fumes from diesel powered vehicles would have when passing by or working in the vicinity of fire detection sensors. The findings from the fire tests, however, illustrated that fires can already be burning with life threatening results and not yet be flagged to control room operators for emergency response. Lowering the CO alarm levels could result in numerous alarms from vehicle exhaust fumes and that would lead
to complacency.

Adding the early warning capability of the SO2 as a fire trigger would vastly enhance the fire detection systems without having to lower the CO alarm levels.

Rate of Change

A further enhancement in the integrity of fire detection systems would be to consider the use of Rate of Change as an alarm condition. The “Rate of Change” (ROC) method for additional alarm conditions in this case study is based on a running window of 15-minute and 1-hour accumulated gas sample readings from the gas sensor. The accumulated value is an indication of the last 15 minutes and/or 1 hour that the total gas volume has passed the sensor.

The method is to accumulate the gas reading at a constant sample rate allowing us to average the reading to a 1-minute sample average.

Figure 4: Rate of Change applied as an alarm setting

Figure 4 illustrates how the ROC can vastly improve the early warning alarm conditions when configured in conjunction with the absolute value alarm settings, as discussed above. The dataset collected from the Scada system after a recent fire in an underground coal mine was used to illustrate this concept.

This calculation is based on a 15-minute interval, meaning once the first 15-minute accumulated result is determined, it will only be compared in 15-minute time intervals, therefore looking at the ROC for a 15-minute period instead of every single minute. When the sixteenth minute result is logged, the first minute result will be excluded from the value set.

Under the prevailing conditions of this fire incident, a >2% ROC would be recorded two hours before the fire reaches the flashpoint using a 15-minute interval, and to compliment the 15-minute setting, a 1-hour ROC set at >1% would have recorded about two hours and 30 minutes before the belt burst into flames. The real alarm was triggered at 30ppm, about two minutes after the flashpoint, and in the presence of 3.5m/s velocity in the belt road, the fire was out of control within five minutes.

Smoke or Particle Concentration Sensors

The use of particle sensors as smoke detectors was also tested. The effectiveness of this method for fire detection is illustrated in Figure 5.

A Degree of Safety
Figure 5: Particle concentration as smoke detection

This technology detects the presence of airborne particles and can work very well in the absence of dust, fumes and stone dust applications.

The ROC concept can also be programmed as an early warning alarm indicator. The technology was tried and tested through the years and no further research was done in this regard.

Linear and Thermal Fire Detection Systems

Both these methods of fire detection were proven through the years to be very successful at the point of application. They are not discussed in this report because their effectiveness is known, and no further research was done in this regard.

Constraint 2:

Sensor Location and Placement

Sensor location relative to the ventilation flow direction is paramount to the reaction of the sensor to the gas. Sensors must always be installed in locations where the general body of air would fully flow over the sensor.

Sensor placement is also critical to this effect. Placement refers to the actual position in terms of height, accessibility for maintenance and performance testing, and optimal coverage of the ventilation current. During fire detection testing, as discussed before, it was found that as little as a 1-metre sub-optimal placement can influence the gas reading dramatically and alarm conditions can be missed. Extreme high velocities and harsh environmental conditions must also be avoided because these conditions will affect the sensor lifespan.

Constraint 3:

Telemetric Technician Skills, and Equipment

Incident investigations after fires have occurred, normally focus mainly on the prevailing conditions that could have caused the fire, identifying what preventive controls have failed, and why the telemetric gas detection devices did not warn of an impending danger in progress. This section of the report will briefly discuss the technical matters of telemetric gas detection practices that are paramount to the effectiveness of fire detection systems.

A Degree of Safety

The following matters must, as a minimum, be addressed through training modules to ensure that telemetric technicians are suitably skilled for the task of effectively operating fire detection systems:

  1. Understanding the design, assembly and operation of gas detectors and sensors.
  2. Be familiar with the various types of sensors and how to identify different materials to be monitored.
  3. Common application, limitations, interferences and poisoning of electrochemical sensors.
  4. General overview of fixed installation apparatus, operating instructions, operational checks, cabling, communication network and maintenance requirements.
  5. Workshop calibration kits and equipment, sensor testing and record keeping.
  6. Fixed gas detectors’ receiving, handling, storage and pre-installation checks.
  7. Performance verification through bump testing, e.g. in-situ T90 performance tests.
  8. Calibration gas characteristics composition, gas and flow regulator selection criteria, cannister handling, storage and expiry date management.

General Observations

The following is a summary of general observations from the conveyor belt fire testing:

  1. Conveyor belts do not just burst into flames at the slightest heating incident. It requires a fair duration (between 11 and 21 minutes) of exposure to heat in excess of 500°C for a stationary conveyor belt to start burning.
  2. Damage to conveyor belts, idlers and pulleys may result in the coal underneath the belts to burn. Coal burns easier than the conveyor belt material.
  3. Certain toxins are released during the heating activity before the belt material actually participates in the combustion process.
  4. All belts can burn. Flame-retardant belts, however, burn less material after the heat source is removed. Non flame-retardant belts can incinerate completely.
  5. The more intense the heat generated from the fire, the further the smoke would flow against the airstream in airways with lower prevailing velocities.
  6. Phosgene and sulphur dioxide release was severely aggravated when water was dispersed onto the belt.
  7. Location of detectors is critical to the effectiveness of the detection system.

Conclusion and Recommendations

This case study delivered extremely insightful information for improvement opportunities in the fire detection systems currently deployed in underground coal mines in South Africa.

A Degree of Safety

The extent of this study was appreciated by all stakeholders that participated in this process.

Recommendations to improve the fire detection system effectiveness:

  1. Retain the current CO sensors. Introduce SO2 sensors together with the current CO sensors to enhance the early detection of heating incidences.
  2. Configure all CO and SO2 sensors to alarm with a rate of change according to site specific specifications.

Share this article

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Inus Labuschagne

Inus Labuschagne

Inus Labuschagne is the Senior Manager Ventilation at Sasol Mining in South Africa. He started his mining ventilation career in 1982. He worked at Buffelsfontein and Vaal Reefs Gold Mines and joined Sasol Mining in 1987, where he is still employed. He has extensive experience in mine fire prevention, detection and fire incident management. Sasol Mining is a coal mining company in South Africa and is the largest combined underground coal mining company in the world.

Visit Website

POPULAR POSTS BY Inus Labuschagne

A Degree of Safety

Article

A Degree of Safety

Get email updates

Sign up for the HSME newsletter

Keep up-to-date through the power of email with the region's only industrial health and safety magazine - delivering the latest news and products to satisfy all your occupational safety needs.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

FEATURED ARTICLES

Advertisement

SOCIAL MEDIA

HSME on Facebook

https://www.facebook.com/HSMEMagazine/

Advertisement

SOCIAL MEDIA

HSME on Twitter

hsmemagazine HSME Magazine @hsmemagazine ·
1 Feb

isafe MOBILE announces the immediate availability of the world’s first 5G smartphone for ATEX and IECEx zone 1/21.

The IS540.1 is available immediately, find out more today: https://www.hsmemagazine.com/press-release/is540-1-available-now/

#hsmemagazine #isafeMOBILE #ATEX #IECEx

Reply on Twitter 1620747838971088898 Retweet on Twitter 1620747838971088898 Like on Twitter 1620747838971088898 2 Twitter 1620747838971088898

Advertisement

SUBSCRIBE

Stay up to date with our newsletter

Keep up-to-date through the power of email with the region’s only industrial health and safety magazine – delivering the latest news and products to satisfy all your occupational safety needs.

 

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Subscribe

SUBSCRIBE TO HSME MAGAZINE

5 reasons to subscribe to our digital and print package

  • Stay up to date from anywhere in the world, with instant access to the latest issue straight from your phone, tablet or laptop.
  • Trust that you’re getting the best content from our range of internationally accredited authors.
  • Get full access to our archives and see how occupational safety has evolved with us over the years.
  • Enjoy our monthly newsletter curated with up-to-the-minute news and a selection of editor’s top picks.
  • Hot off the press and straight to your door – look forward to your own glossy copy of HSME, delivered five times a year
Subscribe View Subscription levels

STAY SAFE & INFORMED

Subscribe to the best health & safety articles, news, products and regulations

Find out more

Stay up to date with our newsletter

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

ABOUT

  • About HSME
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us

YOUR ACCOUNT

Sign In Register Account Subscribe to HSME

RESOURCES

Request Media Pack

CONNECT

ACCREDITATIONS

Copyright Bay Publishing 2023. All Rights reserved.

Designed & Built by:
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
Cookie settingsACCEPT
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
CookieDurationDescription
cookielawinfo-checbox-analytics11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
cookielawinfo-checbox-functional11 monthsThe cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
cookielawinfo-checbox-others11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
viewed_cookie_policy11 monthsThe cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.
Functional
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
Performance
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
Analytics
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Advertisement
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
Others
Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
SAVE & ACCEPT